Related Work Comparisons

All Images and Video © Pixar

Soul Joe 1


Our result

33 sec per frame




Naive ray testing

13 sec per frame




[Benard 2014]

14 min, 14 sec per frame




Renderman NPR stylization

44 sec per frame




Soul Joe 2


Our result

26 sec per frame




Naive ray testing

13 sec per frame




[Benard 2014]

19 min, 49 sec per frame




Renderman NPR stylization

165 sec per frame




Horse [Sumner 2004]


Our result

46 sec per frame




Naive ray testing

3 sec per frame




[Benard 2014]

8 min, 35 sec per frame




Renderman NPR stylization

14 sec per frame